RICHMOND, The Virginian-Pilot -- The proposed statewide ban on smoking in many public places, including restaurants, all but died Thursday night when a House subcommittee quickly spiked several smoking bills after an hour of emotional testimony from people on both sides of the issue.
The vote means it's unlikely the Republican-controlled House will entertain the Senate's smoking ban bill, which passed Wednesday. Democrats control the Senate. A statewide smoking ban in restaurants is also a top priority of Gov. Timothy M. Kaine, a Democrat.
The subcommittee of the General Laws Committee also squashed bills to give localities the right to impose their own smoking bans, a blow to cities including Virginia Beach and Norfolk that pushed for the power.
The unanimous action disappointed advocates who said secondhand smoke is dangerous and pleased those who saw the proposed ban as government intrusion into private affairs.
"This gives you some idea how much control lobbyists have," said Del. Algie Howell Jr., D-Norfolk, who sponsored one of the ban bills. "It's unbelievable that a handful of people will decide what's in the best interest of the people of Virginia."
Randy Estenson, owner of Poppa's Pub in Virginia Beach, who said 80 percent of his customers smoke, praised the ruling.
"I'm very happy," he said. "I honestly believe businesses are doing what they need to do on their own."
Delegates who voted against the measure took a similar position.
"It's not up to the government to tell people what to do," said Del. Thomas Gear, R-Hampton, chairman of the General Laws ABC/Gaming subcommittee.
Gear said many of his favorite restaurants in Hampton have decided to ban smoking on their own.
Del. John Cosgrove, R-Chesapeake, who is the only South Hampton Roads lawmaker on the subcommittee, also voted against the bills. Del. Terrie Suit, R-Virginia Beach, who leads the full General Laws Committee, spoke against them.
"The issue has been elevated to the level that so many restaurants have gone smoke free, so it's not longer necessary for the government to do it," Suit said.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
It's nice to know that Virginia hasn't caved to the health fascists at WHO...yet. I do feel like puking when I hear these liberals crying over the loss of the ban, "oh, dear, this shows how powerful the tobacco lobby is...oh, dear, how will we ever protect all those innocent employees?" BLEEAAAAACHHHH...GAG! It takes a special overproduction of GALL for a ban supporter to talk about the tobacco lobby...they're the ones who've steamrolled the freedoms in twenty-three states and counting. Of course, they know this...playing the victim is part of their arsenal.
I also say bravo to The state for refusing to allow localities to put in their own bans...seems the state understands that these bans don't belong in the hands of state or local government, but those of the individual business owners.
Of course, I also see this isn't going to last forever...What the nanny/bullies didn't get this time around will probably happen next session.
Can you direct me to an individual who would be willing to be interviewed or comment on legislation that bans smoking in cars with children?
Brad
Post a Comment